The Greater Love — Context and Discussion
Edition facts
The catalog record for The Greater Love — Context and Discussion provides practical reading context through 30,724 words, 2 hr 14 min estimated reading time, and 4 detected text sections.
The text analysis averages about 20.9 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.
Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “World War, 1914-1918 -- Personal narratives, American,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.
Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.
How this score is calculated
- Description quality20 pts
- Title & short description10 pts
- Source metadata20 pts
- Text length15 pts
- Chapters / structure15 pts
- EPUB file integrity20 pts
Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.
Read the Text
Mine was the privileged and sacred duty, as Vicar General of the Fourteen States comprising the Great Lakes Vicariate, of knowing intimately and directing the splendid work of these heroic soldiers of the Cross. The inspiration I drew, both from these priests and from contact with their work and written reports, whether in cantonments, camps, hospitals, transports, battleships, or on the flaming front of the battlefields, I shall ever treasure and recount with pride.
Archbishop Hayes, appointed by the Holy Father "Chaplain Bishop" in charge of all priests in Military Service, and who conducted the vast responsibilities of that most important work with such eminent success, has declared our Chaplains to be "the Flower of the American Priesthood." One of such is Father McCarthy, Author of this book "The Greater Love." The same zeal that prompted him to follow the boys in Khaki and Blue Over There--making himself one with them in hardship, danger and wounds for the sake of their immortal souls, now impels him to the writing of this Book. "The Greater Love" is a religious message which teaches that as man needed God in war--with a crescendo of need reaching full tide in the front trench--even so he needs him in Peace. The message is clothed in the narrative of adventure--personal experiences of the Author--and every page an epic of absorbing interest. No one is better qualified to bring us message from Over There.
RT. REV. MSGR. WM. M. FOLEY, V. G.
"THE GREATER LOVE" BY GEORGE T. MCCARTHY, Chaplain, U. S. Army
LEAVE HOME--BASE HOSPITAL NO. 11--CAMP DODGE
"Very well then, Father, you have my permission and best wishes."
How the approving words and blessing of good Archbishop Mundelein thrilled me that memorable morning in 1918. The rain-washed freshness of April was abroad in Cass street; and the soft breeze, swaying the curtain of the Chancery window where he was seated, brought incense of budding tree and garden.
Patiently he had listened, while I presented my reasons for wishing to become a war Chaplain. How, obedient to that call to National Service which is
"The pride of each patriot's devotion,"
millions of our boys were exchanging the shelter of home and parish influence for the privation and danger of camp and ship and battlefield.
To accompany them, to encourage them, to administer to their spiritual and moral needs, to fortify their last heroic hours with "Sacramenta propter homines," here was a Christlike work pre-eminently worthy the best traditions of the Priesthood.
Even as, earnestly, I pleaded my case, I bore steadily in mind recollection of that lofty patriotism and brilliant leadership which had already made Chicago's Archbishop a foremost National Champion. It was but yesterday that the Secretary of the United States Treasury had called, personally, to thank and congratulate him on his inspiring patronage of Loan and Red Cross Drives.
In the sympathetic glow of his face I read approval even before hearing the formal words of permission.
"Moreover, Father, I will appoint an administrator at once, to care for the parish during your absence. You will receive, through Father Foley's office, letters duly accrediting you to Bishop Hayes, Chaplain Ordinary, and the National authorities."
A fond ambition, long cherished, was about to be realized! I had, of course, been doing something of a war "bit," co-operating with parishioners, and town folks like Mayor Gibson and Doctor Noble, in the various patriotic rallies and drives. Father Shannon of the "New World" thought so highly of our city's efforts as to visit us and eloquently say so at a monster Mass Meeting of citizens. "Do you know, George," he remarked that night as he marched beside me in the street parade, "if I could only get away, I would gladly go as a Chaplain."
Then I told him my secret, how I had filed my war application some months before, and had been meanwhile seasoning my body to the out-of-doors and practicing long hikes.
But a single cloud now remained in the radiant sky of dreams--the thought of parting! Ten years of residence in so Arcadian a place as Myrtle Avenue, and in so American a town as Harvey, engender ties of affection not easily to be sundered. Then, too, the school children, how one grows to love them, especially when you have given them their first Sacraments, and even joined in wedlock their parents before them. Of course for the priest who, more perhaps than any other man, "has not here a lasting city," whose life is so largely lived for others, and whose "Holy Orders" so naturally merge with marching orders, the leave-taking should not have been so trying. Preferable as would have been
"No moaning of the bar When I put out to sea,"
Chaplain George T. McCarthy's memoir opens with a preface that frames the war as a crucible of moral character, asserting that Providence transforms the commonplace into the sacred. The narrative then drops into the immediacy of October 1918: McCarthy, gassed four hours earlier, conducts services in a dugout at Vieville-en-Haye, then attempts a harrowing dash through shellfire in a Harley-Davidson side-car. The prose oscillates between lofty spiritual rhetoric and gritty tactical detail—the two-minute intervals of German eight-inch howitzers, the ruined church, the prayer 'Not my will but Thine be done.' This tension between the eternal and the urgent defines the work.
The Chaplain as Combatant
McCarthy does not present himself as a passive observer. He is gassed, wounded by shrapnel, and repeatedly exposed to direct fire. His account of the dash through Vieville-en-Haye—timing the shell bursts, fouling the motorcycle in a crater, the prayer before the next round—reads like a combat report. The medical officer's laconic 'Chaplain, you are gassed' and later 'Well, Chaplain, they winged you this time' underscore a matter-of-fact acceptance of risk. McCarthy's role blurs the line between spiritual caregiver and frontline soldier, a pattern visible in his description of the guns named 'President's Answer,' 'Theda Bara,' and 'Miss McCarthy'—mixing patriotism, popular culture, and personal connection.
Sacred Spaces Under Fire
The ruined church at Vieville-en-Haye becomes a recurring motif. McCarthy recalls 'the countless times Holy Mass had been offered there' even as he uses it as a landmark in a life-or-death gamble. The dugout where he holds services is 'carefully hidden in a forest'; the roadside becomes 'sanctuary and choir.' This juxtaposition of the sacred and the shattered is deliberate. The preface's language of 'the water of the commonplace' becoming 'wine of Cana' finds its physical counterpart in these improvised altars. McCarthy's faith is not abstract—it is embedded in the landscape of craters, gas waves, and the 'sickening report' of incoming shells.
Voice and Structure: The Memoir's Dual Register
The text shifts between two distinct registers. The preface employs a formal, homiletic tone—'God is in His world and has care of it!'—while the narrative chapters are terse, action-driven, and laced with vernacular. Corporal Plummer's 'Sure, we can make it' and Captain Cash's 'they winged you this time' ground the story in spoken language. The chapter titles ('The Greater Love,' 'Thiacourt—Aerial Daring') hint at a thematic arc, but the excerpts show a writer more comfortable with incident than reflection. The gas attack is described in technical detail—'the clasp was on his nose, the tube in his mouth'—before yielding to the simple diagnosis. This dual voice suggests a tension between the chaplain's public role and the soldier's private experience.
Readers should attend to how McCarthy negotiates the gap between his prefatory idealism and the chaos he records. The memoir is not a systematic theology of war but a collection of moments—some harrowing, some mundane—filtered through a priest's sensibility. The incomplete excerpts leave questions about how the narrative resolves this tension, but the pattern is clear: faith is tested not in quiet chapels but on roads swept by shellfire, in gas-filled dugouts, and beside the wounded. The book rewards those who read for texture rather than argument.
There are no reviews for this eBook.
What did you think of this book?
Answer a few questions and save a private reflection on this device.